Saturday, February 9, 2013

Mirror, Mirror on the Wall



From a young age, girls especially, learn that “thin is in”. That image is shaped by our parents, peers, media, and experiences. I have been involved with dance since I was six years old and even then I was informed of the ideal thin. It wasn’t until I was ten that I started not only judging my body, but the other girls’ bodies in my classes. As a dancer, you are in front of full length mirrors for multiple hours a day.  Instead of solely focusing on group formation, and making sure your own body is correctly aligned and in the correct position, you can easily become fixated on body flaws. I started looking at other girls and pinpointing all of their flaws; their thighs are too big, their stomachs aren’t flat enough, etc. I then started watching myself in the mirror and realized every visible and physical flaw on myself. I too realized that my thighs didn’t touch, my arms were not toned enough, my hips were to wide, etc.  It was then at age eleven I started my struggle with anorexia.   For years I had unrealistic body ideals that I felt I needed to strive to achieve.  Instead of having instructors who encouraged a healthy lifestyle, they too encouraged cutting back food/calorie intake as well as increasing intensive exercising.

            We all have body prejudices when we think of athletes.  How would you describe the perfect dancers’ body?  I always envision a ballet dancer as having “the perfect body”.  Every muscle and body part is elongated; legs, stomach, neck and arms to name a few.  The outside world thinks that dancers carry themselves with such poise, when really many of them are in a constant battle to maintain the ideal dance body. 

            There have been many studies done to pinpoint what really contributes to the influences of distorted body images among dancers.  While many dance schools and studios are now trying to promote healthy eating habits and positive body image, there is still the underlying factor of what is socially accepted in the dance world.  A former ballerina who used to dance with the New York City Ballet Company stated, “I was less than a hundred pounds even then….He did not merely say, ‘Eat less.’  He said repeatedly, ‘Eat nothing’” (Oliver, p. 21).  Her dance instructor did not care about her well-being, he cared about the image she was portraying on stage.  Like many dance instructors, they strive to have the best of everything; choreography, costumes, music, dancers, etc.  When dancing for such a big company, the image that is portrayed on stage silently speaks about what your company is about.  Dancers strive to be the best and do all they can to reach the potential that their instructors provide to them.  But how do you not let it go too far?  How do you find a healthy balance between a healthy weight and a weight that your dance company expects from you? In many dance companies, this is a struggle that dancers go through on a daily basis.

            Many dance studios and companies have wall to wall full length mirrors that help dancers self-monitor their movement.  However, the mirrors also allow room for dancers to critique every aspect of their body.  Oliver (2008) states “The mirror provides constant feedback about the movement and shape of our bodies.  Most people are drawn strongly to visual stimuli, so if a mirror is present, it may overshadow and proprioceptive feedback the dancers might receive...But unfortunately, they can also become a conduit for negative self-talk”(Oliver, p. 22).   Dance is an art that allows us to freely express ourselves through movement, but with a constant reminder of societal pressures such as body image, that we may be trying to escape, we are setting ourselves up for disappointment having to constantly monitor our bodies.

            As the American culture continues to obsess over beauty and weight, there needs to be an increase in the promotion of being healthy and happy.  In the dance world especially, I firmly believe that the instructors need to be more supportive and focus on the dancers’ body movement and potential to grow.  As a society, we need to learn to let go of our biases and realize there is potential for real talent no matter a person’s size, shape, or color.

 

Oliver, W. (2008). Body image in the dance class. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 79(5), 18-25.

5 comments:

  1. I witnessed a similar scenario in wrestling. A friend of mine was told by his doctor that he was burning muscle tissue in a quest to make weight. When he told the coach he was informed that he should "man up" or quit. He quit. I would assume that many dance instructors are former dancers themselves. Do you think it is a cycle of them being treated that way so they feel they must pass it along?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, it is a shame how body images are still being critiqued, even if these dancers are extremely talented. It is amazing how society sometimes can’t seem to comprehend, why so many young kids today have eating disorders due to lack of self-confidence on how they feel about themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is a shame that so many young girls feel so inadequate about themselves. I had a friend in college that battled anorexia. She was (and still is) such a beautiful person; on the outside and inside! I couldn't imagine the battles she fought with herself, and what she put her body through. It must have been difficult. Like many women, I too struggle with my weight, and what I think I should look like. But, I have realized through the years that I must do what make me feel good. I may not be really thin, but I workout, and it makes me feel good. Workouts give me energy, and improves my mood! If people could focus more on feeling good, what a difference it would make.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The dance world is so brutal, like modeling as well. When I look at women on the runway, with arms that look like famine victims, it makes me crazy. That is not sexy, or healthy. My daughter is a tiny snippet of a thing at age 10. When she sits in the tub, she has tiny rolls of skin, literally normal skin on a very flat stomach. She looks at it and says "I am fat". It is the skin that is holding her insides in, there is no extra flesh whatsoever. I already see the chubby kids in her class do not get played with like the other thin girls do. We are all so conditioned. It is just as bad for men, who are supposed to have 6 pack abs and broad shoulders, pressure is everywhere...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Love your quote, "As a society, we need to learn to let go of our biases and realize there is potential for real talent no matter a person's size, shape, or color." To me I think the pressure on women in general and in dance to fit this "ideal" body image is unrealistic. Also that society and media are the ones to fuel women's insecurities that potentially lead eating disorders such as anorexia and bullimia. What makes the world such a diverse and unique place is the beauty of the people that surround us. Woman should not have these boundaries and forced to meet these expectations that demand them to be unhealthy and malnourished. We are all beautiful in our own way and need to embrace the things that make us different, not be told to conform to these unrealistic and unhealthy standards.

    ReplyDelete